A shortlist is useful only when the options fit the way your business works. For an Albany owner planning a change, starting with popular products or providers can create a long list without revealing which option addresses the actual problem.
Use the following steps to build a practical shortlist for one operational need. The options may include a changed internal process, extra assistance or a new tool. Keeping those possibilities open helps you avoid buying a product before deciding what work needs to improve.
Step 1: choose one workflow to examine
Identify a clear start and finish. You could examine how an accepted order becomes a prepared collection, or how a supplier invoice reaches the person authorised to review it. “Improve administration” is too broad to guide a useful shortlist.
Walk through the current task with the people who do it. Note information received, decisions made, handovers and unfinished work. Include the exception that causes the most difficulty, rather than describing only the smoothest case.
Keep customer details out of the planning notes unless they are necessary and handled appropriately. A fictional example can illustrate the sequence without making a genuine customer record part of a supplier demonstration.
Step 2: state the result and constraints
Describe what a better workflow would achieve in observable terms. For instance, the person preparing a collection should be able to see the latest accepted order and know whether anything remains unresolved. That is clearer than asking for a modern system.
Business.gov.au’s goal-setting guidance asks businesses to consider resources, skills and realistic timeframes. Use those constraints when defining what an option must fit.
Record your available budget, staff capacity, equipment and timing. If the change must work with an existing accounting service or a particular staff role, name that dependency. Separate a genuine requirement from a preference that could be adjusted.
Step 3: list different ways to meet the need
Create a broad initial list before selecting products. One option might be clearer responsibility and a better existing template. Another might be configuring a function you already pay for. A third might involve a different service or outside assistance.
Describe each option using the same task. Ask what it would change, what it would leave with staff and which new responsibilities it creates. An option that removes one handover may introduce a different checking task.
For an Albany business working across several sites, consider the actual circumstances at those sites. Do not assume a process tested at the main office will be equally practical for someone completing work elsewhere.
Step 4: apply a small set of essential filters
Remove options that cannot meet a documented essential requirement. Keep a note of the reason, particularly if a missing detail could be clarified later. Unknown capability is different from confirmed unsuitability.
- Can the option complete the core task and important exception?
- Does it fit the staff roles and equipment involved?
- Can it work with essential existing services?
- Can your business manage its setup and ongoing work?
- Are important records accessible and portable?
- Are the likely costs within the available resources?
Keep the shortlist manageable enough to investigate properly. There is no special number that makes it good; the useful size depends on how many credible alternatives remain and how much evaluation your team can complete.
Step 5: ask for evidence using the same task
Show each remaining option the same workflow and ask how it would handle it. Where a supplier is involved, request a demonstration of the ordinary case and the difficult exception. Ask what is standard, what needs configuration and what costs extra.
Business.gov.au’s digital tools guidance recommends distinguishing essential and optional features, considering total ownership costs and trialling tools. A demonstration is more useful when it tests your requirements rather than following a supplier’s easiest example.
Record evidence and questions beside each option. Avoid awarding a high score for an impressive feature that has no role in the workflow. Include staff feedback about clarity, effort and the practical consequences of mistakes.
Let different staff try the same task where practical. A process that works only when its designer is present may require more documentation or a simpler design. Treat that as evidence about the option, rather than assuming unfamiliar staff are the source of every difficulty.
Step 6: compare the whole operating arrangement
Compare setup, routine work, exceptions, support and exit over a consistent period. Separate known charges from estimates and unanswered questions. Include the internal time needed for training, record preparation and review.
Ask what happens if the option does not work as expected. A small reversible trial may be appropriate before a larger commitment. Define its purpose, review point and the existing process that remains in use while testing.
Finish with a short decision record: the preferred option, why it fits, the limits accepted and what must be checked before proceeding. Your Albany business then has a shortlist grounded in real work, with a clear route from planning to an informed decision.